THE VALUE OF PSYCHOMETRIC TESTS IN RECRUITMENT

Sharp Consultancy’s Salary Survey 2026/27: Finding the Best Talent in a Competitive Yorkshire Finance Market

Over the past 12 months, the Yorkshire finance and accountancy employment market has entered a relatively stable period following several years of volatility and rapid salary inflation.Hiring activity remains consistent across most finance disciplines, however employers are adopting a more cautious and measured approach to permanent recruitment, likely borne from the economic uncertainty businesses are navigating. As a result, there has been a wider increase across interim hires and salary movement has become more controlled with recruitment processes taking longer than in previous years. Despite this stabilisation, skills shortages continue to be a defining feature of the market. This is particularly evident between the qualified and senior level, where replacement hiring in key roles continues to exceed the available candidate pool and the data reflected in this salary survey aligns closely with what we are seeing daily across the Yorkshire finance market. While hiring volumes have levelled out, the underlying challenge remains unchanged: demand for high-quality finance professionals continues to outweigh supply. What the data does not always fully capture, but we have seen consistently across the market, is the increasing complexity behind each hire. Employers are no longer simply recruiting for technical capability; they are seeking finance professionals who can influence, adapt and add value, often in uncertain trading conditions. This has resulted in longer recruitment timelines, narrower shortlists and a growing reliance on trusted market insight to secure the right individuals. Across the candidate market we are seeing a more selective approach to new opportunities. Job seekers are making increasingly considered career decisions, weighing role scope, leadership quality, flexibility and long-term opportunity alongside salary. Many of the strongest candidates are not actively applying for roles, which means traditional, employer led recruitment strategies are no longer sufficient. Employers are no longer simply recruiting for technical capability; they are seeking finance professionals who can influence, adapt and add value, often in uncertain trading conditions.This is where a relationship-driven recruitment partner becomes vital. At Sharp Consultancy, and through our work with our executive division - The CFO Partnership - our long-standing relationships across the South Yorkshire finance community allow us to engage with high-performing talent that is not always visible to the wider market. Our understanding of both client environments and individual career motivations enables us to make introductions that are aligned not just on skills, but on culture, ambition and long-term fit. In a market where salary growth is increasingly controlled and competition for talent remains intense, our ability to advise, challenge and guide both clients and candidates is vital. Recruitment partnerships built on trust, transparency and deep market knowledge are what ultimately ensure the best outcomes - securing the right talent for our clients, and the right opportunities for the candidates we represent.

Read article

For many organisations, psychometric tests play an essential role in the recruitment process. Used effectively, they can provide an insight into a candidate’s personality traits and behaviours providing would-be employers with information about their character, strengths, weaknesses, motivations and working styles which cannot be gleaned from a CV – or even interview – alone.

When adopting psychometric testing as part of wide-ranging recruitment strategy it is important to remember that these should not be used in isolation to make decisions on whether to progress with a candidate; there are no right or wrong answers, and an individual cannot be seen to pass or fail.

So, in what way are they beneficial to employers? Interviews, whilst useful in assessing candidates against specific characteristics, skills and attributes, are often subjective. A psychometric analysis can provide an employer with measurable and objective ‘data’ which they are then able to utilise effectively within the recruitment process - typically either in the very early stages to shape interview questioning or to confirm a final selection once the field has been whittled down.

The results produced from a psychometric test adds real value to an employer’s decision-making ability; they enable more accurate judgements to be made about, for example, how a person may gel with existing team members, how they approach leadership challenges, what their management style is to ensure the ideal candidate is selected.

These valuable insights are not just confined to the recruitment process; they offer ongoing opportunities for conversations around role development, career progression, job satisfaction and employee engagement.

There are potential pitfalls however, if such tests and their subsequent results are not administered or used correctly. For example, if an employer rejects an applicant because they do, or do not, display certain traits – say a particular approach to leadership - they may find that they inadvertently overlook an otherwise strong candidate for the role.

In addition, verbal reasoning and numerical assessments can also be a useful tool and enable employers to set candidates a minimum competency bar. As with psychometric tests, the maximum benefit is gained when the results of these are used to guide decision making as part of a suite of assessment methods.

Cost factors of such assessments can prove prohibitive for some; however, effective recruitment must be seen as an investment and when used as part of a robust, well rounded hiring process, the benefits can enable employers get the right people on board to reap some valuable rewards.

Sharp Consultancy specialises in the recruitment and executive search of finance and accountancy professionals. With offices in Leeds and Sheffield our highly experienced team of consultants recruit for temporary, interim and permanent roles across the full spectrum of positions throughout Yorkshire and beyond. CONTACT US today and speak to a member of our team about your recruitment needs or next career move.